Deciding how to sell your farmland is one of the most significant financial decisions you’ll make as a landowner. With multiple methods available—each offering distinct advantages—understanding your options is crucial for maximizing your property’s value. As agricultural real estate specialists at Whitaker Marketing Group, we’ve guided countless Iowa landowners through this important decision process. Let’s explore the key considerations to help you determine whether listing or auctioning your farm is the right choice for your situation.
Understanding Your Selling Options
Wondering whether to list or auction your farm? It’s a substantial decision that can significantly impact your bottom line. Each approach has its own strengths and attracts different buyers depending on your property type, location, ownership history, time constraints, and reasons for selling.
Traditional Listing: The Conventional Approach
Traditional listing remains the most common approach to selling land nationwide. This method sets an asking price and opens the door for negotiations with potential buyers. When you choose a traditional listing with experienced agricultural brokers, your property stays visible longer, reaching buyers using 1031 exchanges or those who need financing. This approach offers a flexible timeline, allowing you to take your time reviewing offers and negotiating better terms while maintaining greater influence over sale conditions.
However, traditional listings may take longer to complete, particularly in today’s market with a smaller buyer pool. Property values could also fluctuate during the listing period, sometimes resulting in a lower final price than initially anticipated.
Best for: Recreational land, improved farms, development sites, or properties that aren’t easily subdivided.
Off-Market Listing: The Discreet Option
Off-market sales happen without publicly listing your property, offering a more discreet selling approach. This method provides maximum confidentiality throughout the process and allows for direct negotiations with carefully selected, qualified prospects. Off-market listings are perfect for sellers wanting leaseback options to continue farming after sale or for those seeking to improve value before marketing the property.
Challenges: Reduced visibility may limit your property’s exposure and make it harder to reach top market value. Fewer buyers often mean longer selling timelines and more difficulty establishing a true market price.
Public Auctions: Creating Competition
Auctions have gained significant popularity across the Midwest, especially for high-quality tillable farmland. Competitive bidding establishes true market value quickly and creates urgency through specific deadlines. Auctions ensure all buyers operate under the same transparent conditions—motivating them to compete fairly and bid confidently.
Best for: Premium farmland, estate and trust sales, or properties with multiple interested parties.
Challenges: Final sale price is unpredictable until auction day, and outcomes depend on market timing and exposure.
Online Auctions: Modern Flexibility
Online auctions mirror traditional live auctions but occur digitally, expanding access to bidders statewide and nationally. They work especially well for smaller tracts, recreational land, and transitional properties near development zones.
Sealed Bid Auction: The Confidential Approach
Sealed bid auctions combine privacy with competition. Buyers submit confidential offers directly to the seller or broker, which encourages strong opening bids and allows for specialized terms, such as financing or extended closings. While they may not create the same energy as public auctions, sealed bids are excellent for large tracts, specialty farms, or properties with unique features.
Comparing Key Elements Across Selling Methods
- Visibility & Audience: Public listings and auctions offer broad exposure. Off-market listings target qualified buyers privately.
- Confidentiality: Off-market listings rank highest; sealed bids provide moderate privacy.
- Marketing: All methods use photos, videos, print, and digital ads. Only traditional listings advertise price; off-market listings typically limit public promotion.
- Process: Each begins with goal setting and due diligence. Off-market listings uniquely include asset optimization and buyer screening.
Finding Your Best Path Forward
There’s no one-size-fits-all approach to selling farmland. Every property and seller have unique goals and timing. As your trusted land professionals at Whitaker Marketing Group, we’re committed to helping you evaluate every option—ensuring you select the method that fits your needs, maximizes value, and reduces stress.
Whether you choose a traditional listing, off-market sale, or auction process, expert guidance can make the difference between a standard sale and an outstanding result.
Ready to explore your options? Contact David Whitaker at 515-460-8585 to discuss your property and selling goals in detail.
Want to view our free flyer? Click here.
David Whitaker | Iowa Land Guy
Whitaker Marketing Group
Choosing whether to list or auction your Iowa farmland depends on timing, property type, and goals. Whitaker Marketing Group helps landowners find the best strategy for maximum return.
